All-Century Team
| First Name | Last Name | College | Pos. | Team | Game | Date | Year |
| Earl "Dutch" | Clark | Colorado College | Q | West | 5 | Jan. 1 | 1930 |
| Bronko | Nagurski | Minnesota | T | East | 5 | Jan. 1 | 1930 |
| Albert Glen "Turk" | Edwards | Washington State | T | West | 7 | Jan. 1 | 1932 |
| William "Bill" | Hewitt | Michigan | E | East | 7 | Jan. 1 | 1932 |
| Clarke "Hink" | Hinkle | Bucknell | B | East | 7 | Jan. 1 | 1932 |
| Joe | Stydahar | West Virginia | T | East | 10 | Jan. 1 | 1936 |
| Daniel | Fortmann | Colgate | G | East | 11 | Jan. 1 | 1936 |
| Clarence "Ace" | Parker | Duke | H | East | 12 | Jan. 1 | 1937 |
| Alex | Wojciechowicz | Fordham | C | East | 13 | Jan. 1 | 1938 |
| George | McAfee | Duke | B | East | 15 | Jan. 1 | 1940 |
| Clyde (Bulldog) | Turner | Hardin-Simmons | C | West | 15 | Jan. 1 | 1940 |
| Jimmy | Johnson | UC Santa Clara | H | West | 16 | Jan. 1 | 1941 |
| Bill | Dudley | Virginia | B | East | 17 | Jan. 3 | 1942 |
| Bob | Waterfield | UCLA | Q | West | 20 | Jan. 1 | 1945 |
| Doak | Walker | Southern Methodist | B | West | 21 | Jan. 1 | 1946 |
| Peter | Pihos | Indiana | E | East | 22 | Jan. 1 | 1947 |
| George | Connor | Notre Dame | T | East | 23 | Jan. 1 | 1948 |
| Tom | Fears | UCLA | E | West | 23 | Jan. 1 | 1948 |
| Ernest | Stautner | Boston College | TE | East | 23 | Jan. 1 | 1948 |
| Arnie | Weinmeister | Washington | T | West | 23 | Jan. 1 | 1948 |
| James "Jim" | Finks | Tulsa | B | West | 24 | Jan. 1 | 1949 |
| Michael | McCormack | Kansas | T | West | 26 | Dec. 30 | 1950 |
| Dick | Stanfel | San Francisco Dons | G | West | 26 | Dec. 30 | 1950 |
| Frank | Gifford | UCLA | B | West | 27 | Dec. 29 | 1951 |
| Gino | Marchetti | UC San Francisco | G | West | 27 | Dec. 29 | 1951 |
| Ollie | Matson | UC San Francisco | B | West | 27 | Dec. 29 | 1951 |
| Leslie (Les) | Richter | UC Berkeley | G | West | 27 | Dec. 29 | 1951 |
| Hugh | McElhenny | Washington | B | West | 28 | Dec. 27 | 1952 |
| Raymond | Berry | Southern Methodist | E | West | 30 | Jan. 1 | 1955 |
| Forrest | Gregg | Southern Methodist | T | West | 31 | Dec. 31 | 1955 |
| Leonard "Lenny" | Moore | Penn State | B | East | 31 | Dec. 31 | 1955 |
| Paul | Hornung | Notre Dame | B | East | 32 | Dec. 29 | 1956 |
| Jim | Parker | Ohio State | G | East | 32 | Dec. 29 | 1956 |
| Jerry | Kramer | Idaho | G | West | 33 | Dec. 28 | 1957 |
| Herbert | Adderly | Michigan State | B | East | 36 | Dec. 31 | 1960 |
| Mike | Ditka | Pittsburgh | E | East | 36 | Dec. 31 | 1960 |
| Bob | Lilly | Texas Christian | T | West | 36 | Dec. 31 | 1960 |
| Larry | Wilson | Utah | B | West | 35 | Jan. 2 | 1960 |
| Nick | Buoniconti | Notre Dame | DL | East | 37 | Dec. 30 | 1961 |
| John | Hadl | Kansas | B | West | 37 | Dec. 30 | 1961 |
| Merlin | Olsen | Utah State | T | West | 37 | Dec. 30 | 1961 |
| John | Mackey | Syracuse | E | East | 38 | Dec. 29 | 1962 |
| Carl | Eller | Minnesota | T | East | 39 | Dec. 28 | 1963 |
| Paul | Krause | Iowa | B | East | 39 | Dec. 28 | 1963 |
| Charles | Taylor | Arizona State | B | West | 39 | Dec. 28 | 1963 |
| Paul | Warfield | Ohio State | B | East | 39 | Dec. 28 | 1963 |
| Dick | Butkus | Illinois | C | East | 40 | Jan. 2 | 1965 |
| Thomas (Tom) | Mack | Michigan | G | East | 41 | Dec. 31 | 1965 |
| Gale | Sayers | Kansas | B | West | 40 | Jan. 2 | 1965 |
| Roger | Staubach | Navy | B | East | 40 | Jan. 2 | 1965 |
| Alan | Page | Notre Dame | DE | East | 42 | Dec. 31 | 1966 |
| Curley | Culp | Arizona State | DT | West | 43 | Dec. 30 | 1967 |
| Larry | Csonka | Syracuse | B | East | 43 | Dec. 30 | 1967 |
| Joe | Greene | North Texas | DT | West | 44 | Dec. 28 | 1968 |
| Dan | Dierdorf | Michigan | T | East | 46 | Jan. 2 | 1971 |
| Jack | Ham | Penn State | LB | East | 46 | Jan. 2 | 1971 |
| Joe | DeLamielleure | Michigan State | OT | East | 48 | Dec. 30 | 1972 |
| Mike | Webster | Wisconsin | C | East | 49 | Dec. 29 | 1973 |
| Fred | Dean | Louisiana Tech | LB | East | 50 | Dec. 28 | 1974 |
| Walter | Payton | Jackson State | RB | East | 50 | Dec. 28 | 1974 |
| Randy | White | Maryland | DT | East | 50 | Dec. 28 | 1974 |
| Robert | Brazile | Jackson State | LB | East | 50 | Dec. 28 | 1974 |
| Mike | Haynes | Arizona State | DB | West | 51 | Jan. 3 | 1976 |
| Tony | Dungy | Minnesota | Q | East | 53 | Dec. 31 | 1977 |
| Doug | Williams | Grambling State | Q | East | 53 | Dec. 31 | 1977 |
| Kellen | Winslow | Missouri | TE | West | 54 | Jan. 6 | 1979 |
| Art | Monk | Syracuse | WR | East | 55 | Jan. 5 | 1980 |
| Dwight | Stephenson | Alabama | C | East | 55 | Jan. 5 | 1980 |
| Russ | Grimm | Pittsburgh | OL | East | 56 | Jan. 10 | 1981 |
| Ricky | Jackson | Pittsburgh | LB | East | 56 | Jan. 10 | 1981 |
| Lawrence | Taylor | North Carolina | LB | East | 56 | Jan. 10 | 1981 |
| John | Elway | Stanford | Q | West | 58 | Jan. 15 | 1983 |
| Chris | Doleman | Pittsburgh | DL | East | 60 | Jan. 5 | 1985 |
| Randall | Cunningham | Nevada-Las Vegas | QB | West | 60 | Jan. 5 | 1985 |
| Randall | McDaniel | Arizona State | OL | West | 63 | Jan. 16 | 1988 |
| Sterling | Sharpe | South Carolina | WR | East | 63 | Jan. 16 | 1988 |
| Steve | Atwater | Arkansas | DB | West | 64 | Jan. 15 | 1989 |
| Andre | Rison | Michigan State | WR | East | 64 | Jan. 15 | 1989 |
| Shannon | Sharpe | Savannah State | WR | East | 65 | Jan. 21 | 1990 |
| Brett | Favre | Southern Mississippi | OB | East | 66 | Jan. 26 | 1991 |
| Troy | Vincent | Wisconsin | CB/DB | East | 67 | Jan. 19 | 1992 |
| Will | Shields | Nebraska | OG | West | 68 | Jan. 24 | 1993 |
| Willie | Roaf | Louisiana Tech | OT | East | 68 | Jan. 24 | 1993 |
| Lorenzo | Neal | Fresno State | FB | West | 68 | Jan. 24 | 1993 |
| Larry | Allen | Sonoma State | OT/G | West | 69 | Jan. 15 | 1994 |
| Willie | Brown | Temple | OLB | East | 71 | Jan. 13 | 1996 |
| Zach | Thomas | Texas Tech | MLB | West | 71 | Jan. 13 | 1996 |
| Tedy | Bruschi | Arizona | DE | West | 71 | Jan. 13 | 1996 |
| La'Roi | Glover | San Diego State | DT | West | 71 | Jan. 13 | 1996 |
| Eddie | George | Ohio State | RB | East | 71 | Jan. 13 | 1996 |
| Mike | Vrabel | Ohio State | DE | East | 72 | Jan. 11 | 1997 |
| Jeff | Saturday | North Carolina | OC | East | 73 | Jan. 10 | 1998 |
| Pat | Tillman | Arizona State | OLB | West | 73 | Jan. 10 | 1998 |
| Tom | Brady | Michigan | QB | East | 75 | Jan. 15 | 2000 |
| Steve | Smith | Utah | WR | West | 76 | Jan. 13 | 2001 |
| Jared | Allen | Idaho State | DL | West | 79 | Jan. 10 | 2004 |
| Wes | Welker | Texas Tech | WR | West | 79 | Jan. 10 | 2004 |
| Logan | Mankins | Fresno State | OL | West | 80 | Jan. 15 | 2005 |
| Andrew | Whitworth | Louisiana State | OL | East | 81 | Jan. 21 | 2006 |
| Kam | Chancellor | Virginia Tech | DB | East | 85 | Jan. 23 | 2010 |
